Blue Moon ice cream has long been a subject of fascination, with its unique and elusive flavor sparking curiosity among fans and ice cream enthusiasts. The treat, first introduced in the 1930s, has evolved over the decades, leaving many to wonder: what exactly is the flavor of Blue Moon?
Historical records shed light on its debut. In 1936, The Charleston Gazette in West Virginia described the ice cream as “a fruit mixture with a delightful flavor and color.” A 1949 advertisement in Massachusetts dubbed it “a flavor of its own,” but the question of what defines that flavor remains open to interpretation.
An Ice Cream Flavor That Varies by Region
The flavor of Blue Moon ice cream depends largely on where you buy it. When Cedar Crest Ice Cream, based in Cedarburg, Wisconsin, introduced its own version in the 1970s, it offered no official description of the flavor, leaving customers to determine it for themselves. Many came to the conclusion that it tasted like Froot Loops cereal. Today, Cedar Crest’s version features a distinct almond flavor, but other brands have different takes.
For instance, Babcock Dairy Store in Madison, Wisconsin, offers a Blue Moon that is described as berry-flavored, while Chocolate Shoppe, also in Madison, describes their version as tasting “like the milk in the bottom of a bowl of Froot Loops.” Meanwhile, Guernsey and Ashby’s versions are typically fruity, with Ashby’s also incorporating a nutty taste.
Perry’s Ice Cream, based in Akron, New York, markets its “cosmic blue” variant as a “mystery flavor” with hints of fruit, spice, and vanilla. Hudsonville Ice Cream, which also offers Blue Moon, refers to its product as having “the indescribable flavor of a clear, blue sky,” describing it as “creamy and smooth” but still shrouded in mystery. Similarly, Kopp’s Frozen Custard in Milwaukee takes a more cryptic approach, calling their Blue Moon flavor a “secret” that “remains a mystery to all (including us).”
Blue Moon and Its Connection to Superhero Ice Cream
Blue Moon is sometimes included in ice cream mixes alongside other fun, colorful varieties, such as “Superman” or “Super Hero” ice creams. For example, Hershey’s Ice Cream (unrelated to the candy company) includes Blue Moon in its tri-flavored Superman ice cream, calling it simply “fruity and fun.”
How to Make Blue Moon at Home
If you’re feeling adventurous and want to try making your own Blue Moon ice cream, there are various recipes circulating that combine ingredients like vanilla pudding mix, raspberry flavoring, lemon oil, and vanilla extract to mimic the iconic and mysterious flavor.
Much like bubblegum, Blue Moon’s flavor might best be described as “Blue Moon”—a unique taste that remains subjective and open to interpretation. Whatever its true flavor may be, it continues to delight ice cream lovers, who appreciate it as much for its playful mystery as for its one-of-a-kind taste.
You Might Be Interested In:
- Why Do You Choose Rita’s Water Ice Gift Card?
- Is Rita’s Italian Ice Worth the Cost? A Deep Dive
- What Makes Rita’s Frozen Custard Flavors So Special?
