Ice cream, a beloved dessert with thousands of years of history, is often seen as a symbol of perfection. But despite its simple ingredients—cream, sugar, and time—manufacturing and transporting frozen confections can be fraught with challenges. The process is not only complex, but the need to keep products cold from factory to consumer makes ice cream susceptible to contamination. Occasionally, foodborne pathogens, allergens, or foreign objects find their way into the mix, leading to recalls aimed at preventing harm to consumers.
Here are some of the most significant ice cream recalls in recent history.
Totally Cool Inc. Faces Listeria Contamination
In May 2024, a routine inspection at Maryland-based Totally Cool Inc. led to the discovery of Listeria monocytogenes, a pathogen that can cause severe illness, including fever, nausea, and, in pregnant women, miscarriages. The contamination prompted a nationwide recall in June 2024, affecting dozens of ice cream products from well-known brands like Hershey’s, Jeni’s, and Friendly’s. Despite no immediate reports of illnesses, the recall devastated the company’s reputation, leading to its bankruptcy filing in August 2024.
Wilcox Ice Cream’s Recall Due to Listeria
In November 2023, Wilcox Ice Cream, based in Vermont, faced a similar issue when its Super Premium Mint Chip flavor tested positive for listeria. The company recalled 45 products, including multiple ice cream bars and gelato varieties, which had been distributed across several northeastern U.S. states. The recall spanned months of production, affecting products sold in grocery stores and co-ops in New York, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Vermont.
Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream Faces Metal Contamination
In late 2023, Jeni’s Splendid Ice Cream initiated a recall of its Buttercream Birthday Cake flavor, after discovering that small pieces of aluminum or stainless steel could have contaminated the ice cream. The recall affected more than 58,000 cases, or over 467,000 individual cartons, highlighting the risks of foreign object contamination in food production.
Egg Contamination Recalls
Two separate ice cream manufacturers recalled products in 2023 due to egg contamination. Weis Markets recalled its Brownie Moose Tracks Ice Cream in August after traces of egg were found in the production line, potentially threatening customers with egg allergies. Similarly, Yarnell Operations issued a recall of its Guilt Free No Sugar Added Homemade Vanilla Ice Cream in October after the unlisted presence of eggs posed a risk to allergic consumers.
Canadian Recall Due to Plastic and Metal Fragments
In April 2022, a large-scale recall in Canada involved 13 different types of ice cream, including Baskin-Robbins and President’s Choice, after food safety officials discovered contamination with plastic and metal fragments. Despite the widespread recall, Agropur, the producer, stated that no health issues had been reported.
Royal Ice Cream Recall for Listeria Contamination
In early 2022, the Royal Ice Cream Company issued a recall for several flavors of its Batch ice cream after listeria was detected during FDA testing. The recall expanded rapidly to include multiple other brands and ice cream products sold in states across the U.S., including Massachusetts, Connecticut, and Florida.
Nestlé’s Recall in Spain Over Ethylene Oxide Contamination
In 2021, Nestlé, through its Froneri joint venture, recalled 46 ice cream products in Spain after they were found to contain traces of ethylene oxide, a toxic chemical used in industrial processes. Although the levels were deemed minimal, the recall was implemented as a precautionary measure, underscoring the potential hazards posed by chemical contaminants.
Velvet Ice Cream and Sherbet Recall
In March 2021, Velvet Ice Cream recalled nearly 100 products after discovering possible listeria contamination. The recall covered multiple brands and flavors, but no illnesses were reported at the time. The company took immediate action to prevent potential outbreaks.
Ben & Jerry’s Recall Due to Tree Nut Contamination
In 2019, Ben & Jerry’s issued a recall of two ice cream varieties, Coconut Seven Layer Bar and Chunky Monkey, after it was discovered that they contained undeclared tree nuts. The voluntary recall was issued to prevent allergic reactions to consumers who might have been unaware of the contamination.
The Little Red Rooster Ice Cream Company Recalls Non-Dairy Frozen Desserts
In 2019, Little Red Rooster, known for its NadaMoo! brand of dairy-free frozen desserts, recalled 26,000 pints of its Strawberry Cheesecake Non-Dairy Frozen Dessert due to unlisted almonds, posing a risk to those with tree nut allergies.
Blue Bell’s Historic Recall Due to Listeria Outbreak
One of the most notable ice cream recalls occurred in 2015 when Blue Bell Creameries faced a massive recall due to listeria contamination. The outbreak, which resulted in multiple deaths, was linked to Blue Bell ice cream served in hospitals. The recall ultimately affected ice cream produced at Blue Bell’s Texas and Oklahoma facilities, leading to widespread concerns over food safety and major regulatory penalties for the company.
Kroger’s Nationwide Ice Cream Recall Over Egg Traces
In 2014, Kroger issued a nationwide recall of its Private Selection ice creams after eggs were found to be improperly listed in the ingredients, posing a risk to egg-allergic consumers. No illnesses were reported, but the company urged consumers to return the products for a refund.
Ice cream, while a favorite treat, requires ongoing vigilance during its production and distribution. From bacterial contamination to allergens and foreign objects, manufacturers must take extra precautions to ensure the safety of their products. These recalls serve as stark reminders of the complexities and risks involved in bringing frozen desserts to the public.
You Might Be Interested In:
- Buy Baskin Robbins Ice Cream Online: A Delicious Experience
- Best Chocolate Flavors at Baskin Robbins: Which Ones Stand Out?
- What Is Baskin Robbins’ Plant-Based Ice Cream?
