With an ever-expanding array of ice cream flavors flooding store shelves, making the perfect choice can feel like a daunting task. From quirky flavors like mac and cheese ice cream to time-honored classics, the variety continues to grow. To help you navigate this frozen world, Cheapism has rounded up some of the most exciting ice creams available this year. Whether you’re in the mood for something traditional, adventurous, or even vegan, here are the top picks to consider.
Dreyer’s/Edy’s Slow Churned Classic Vanilla – $4.99 per quart
Vanilla is a classic for a reason, and Dreyer’s (or Edy’s, depending on your region) Slow Churned Vanilla lives up to the hype. Made with fresh milk and cream, and free of artificial colors or flavors, this lighter version offers half the fat of traditional ice creams without sacrificing taste. Widely available across the country, it’s a great budget-friendly option for anyone craving a creamy, smooth treat.
Ben & Jerry’s Cherry Garcia – $6.19 per pint
This iconic flavor remains a favorite among ice cream enthusiasts. Featuring smooth cherry vanilla ice cream with chunks of dark chocolate and real cherry pieces, Cherry Garcia is a rich yet balanced dessert. It’s also non-GMO and hormone-free, available at most major supermarkets like Kroger and Target.
Turkey Hill Trio’politan – $5.50 per quart
Turkey Hill is reinventing the traditional Neapolitan with its Trio’politan range. The new lineup includes exciting combinations like Mint Cookie and Triple Berry. Mint Cookie blends vanilla ice cream, chocolate cookie swirls, and dark chocolate with a minty twist, while Triple Berry layers blueberry, black raspberry, and strawberry ice creams. These innovative flavors provide a refreshing take on a classic.
Lopez Island Decidedly Chocolate – $5.99 per pint
From a small Seattle creamery, Lopez Island’s Decidedly Chocolate offers a velvety chocolate experience. Known for its smooth, melt-in-your-mouth texture, this ice cream is a must-try for chocolate lovers. Available in Washington, Oregon, and Alaska, this pint is perfect for indulgent moments.
Baskin Robbins Pralines & Cream – $4.49 per pint
A nostalgic favorite, Baskin Robbins’ Pralines & Cream features a vanilla base with crunchy pralines and a swirl of caramel. The sweet and salty flavor combination is simply irresistible, and you can find it at most major grocery stores nationwide.
Breyers Delights Caramel Brownie – $4.49 per quart
For a lighter indulgence, Breyers Delights offers a lower-calorie option without compromising on flavor. The Caramel Brownie flavor provides a delicious balance of smooth caramel and rich brownie chunks, with only 360 calories per pint, making it an ideal choice for guilt-free snacking.
Tillamook Marionberry Pie – $5.99 per quart
Marionberries, a unique type of blackberry, are the star of Tillamook’s Marionberry Pie ice cream. Combining these sweet berries with pie crust pieces in a creamy vanilla base, it’s like enjoying a slice of pie a la mode in every bite. Available at retailers across the country, this dessert is a must-try for berry lovers.
McConnell’s Turkish Coffee – $8.99 per pint
Santa Barbara’s McConnell’s Turkish Coffee ice cream is a smooth, rich treat made with espresso flecks and a bold coffee flavor. The dairy-free, gluten-free option offers an authentic Turkish coffee experience in ice cream form. It’s available nationwide and perfect for coffee aficionados seeking something unique.
Gifford’s Maine Wild Blueberry – $4 per quart
Gifford’s Famous Ice Cream, a staple in New England since the 1800s, uses locally sourced ingredients for a distinctive flavor. Maine Wild Blueberry is made with fresh blueberries from Ellsworth, Maine, and has earned acclaim for its rich, fruity taste. You can find Gifford’s ice cream in stores from Maine to the Midwest.
Van Leeuwen Sicilian Pistachio (Non-Dairy) – $7.99 per pint
Van Leeuwen’s Sicilian Pistachio ice cream uses the finest pistachios grown on the slopes of Mount Etna in Sicily. This non-dairy treat, made with cashew and coconut milks, offers a creamy and flavorful vegan alternative that doesn’t skimp on quality. Available nationwide, it’s a standout for those seeking a refined, plant-based ice cream.
Blue Bell Southern Blackberry Cobbler – $7 per half-gallon
For a warm, comforting treat, Blue Bell’s Southern Blackberry Cobbler delivers the essence of homemade pie. Featuring blackberry ice cream with pie crust pieces and a sweet blackberry swirl, this flavor is a summertime favorite. Available in stores nationwide, it’s an easy way to enjoy a slice of pie without turning on the oven.
Magnum Double Almond Brown Butter – $6.49 per tub
Magnum’s Double Almond Brown Butter is a decadent dessert that blends vanilla ice cream with almond ice cream, brown butter sauce, and milk chocolate. This flavor offers a perfect mix of smooth ice cream and crunchy chocolate pieces, providing a luxurious treat with every bite. Find it at major retailers like Target and Walmart.
Haagen-Dazs Amaretto Black Cherry Almond – $4.49 per pint
Haagen-Dazs’ Spirits Collection combines alcohol and ice cream for an adult twist on dessert. The Amaretto Black Cherry Almond flavor features rich amaretto, black cherry jam, and toffee pieces, with a hint of alcohol (less than 0.5% ABV). Available at most grocery stores, it’s an indulgent option for those looking for something unique.
Van Leeuwen Peanut Butter Brownie Honeycomb – $12 per pint
Known for its innovative flavors, Van Leeuwen’s Peanut Butter Brownie Honeycomb is a standout. This vegan dessert combines organic peanut butter, chewy brownies, and honeycomb for a mouthwatering, plant-based experience that’s sure to satisfy even the most discerning sweet tooth.
Talenti Organic Gelato Chocolate Mousse – $6.50 per pint
While technically a gelato, Talenti’s Organic Chocolate Mousse is too delicious to overlook. This rich, chocolatey gelato is swirled with fudge and whipped to perfection, offering a light yet indulgent dessert. Talenti’s gelato is available in most major grocery stores and offers an excellent option for those seeking a smoother, creamier treat.
With so many enticing options available, finding the perfect ice cream has never been easier. Whether you prefer classic flavors or more adventurous creations, these top picks are sure to deliver delicious moments of indulgence.
You Might Be Interested In:
