Inflation has made the simple joy of ice cream a pricier treat, leaving many parents and children frustrated. However, affordable options still exist at fast food chains and supermarkets. One overlooked treasure trove for dessert lovers is big box warehouse stores like Costco and Sam’s Club, both known for their cheap and tasty soft-serve ice cream. But which one is better? Here’s a breakdown.
Sam’s Club Soft-Serve:
Price: $1 for a 10 oz. cup
Flavors: Vanilla or Chocolate
Nutritional Info: 10 grams of protein per serving, relatively low in calories and fat
A taste tester praised Sam’s Club’s fro-yo for its presentation, describing it as “immaculately pulled from the machine with a perfect curl up top.” The vanilla yogurt had a smooth, shiny tan surface and was described as “bittersweet upon first bite” with a “smooth and creamy” texture. The tester found it “quite soothing on a hot afternoon,” noting that it’s hard to beat for the price.
Costco Soft-Serve:
Price: $1.99 for a 10 oz. cup
Flavors: Vanilla or Chocolate
Nutritional Info: Higher in calories and fat compared to Sam’s Club
Costco’s soft-serve was described as “less artfully presented” but still appealing. The chocolate version had a mocha color and was slightly more melty. Despite its appearance, the taste impressed the tester, reminding them of “old-school Jell-O Chocolate Cook & Serve Pudding.” The texture was “airy and light,” making it hard to resist.
The Verdict:
In the end, it’s a matter of preference and budget. Sam’s Club offers a solid, protein-packed soft-serve for just a dollar, making it an unbeatable value. However, Costco’s richer, more indulgent flavor, despite being pricier, offers a nostalgic and satisfying treat.
For those looking to enjoy a delicious and affordable ice cream experience, both Sam’s Club and Costco deliver, but Sam’s Club takes the edge in terms of value, while Costco wins in flavor intensity.
